15 Tips for Interviewing Candidates That Lead to Better Hires

The candidate interview stands as one of the most critical junctures in the hiring process, yet a staggering number of managers conduct them without a clear, systematic strategy. This absence of a structured methodology often culminates in subjective evaluations and pervasive biases, fundamentally undermining the objective of identifying the best possible candidate. An unstructured interview process can be a little more effective than random chance in predicting future job performance [4].

Adopting a more deliberate and thoughtful approach to interviewing, however, can dramatically amplify the predictive power of your hiring decisions. These 15 tips for interviewing candidates provide a comprehensive framework that covers the entire recruitment process, from meticulous preparation to post-interview analysis, equipping recruiters and hiring managers to refine their recruiting techniques and secure superior outcomes.

Before the Interview: Setting the Stage for Success

1. Define the Role with a Job Scorecard

A standard job description is often insufficient for a rigorous candidate evaluation. To forge an objective benchmark, you must develop a "Job Scorecard." This document transcends a simple list of duties, meticulously defining the role's core mission, the key outcomes the candidate is expected to achieve, and the specific competencies essential for success. This scorecard becomes your primary evaluation instrument, providing a consistent set of metrics against which all candidates are measured. This disciplined method is a cornerstone of the topgrading interviewing method, an approach engineered to systematically identify "A-Players," or the top 10% of available talent.

2. Implement a Structured Interview Process

A structured interview is a systematic method wherein all candidates are asked the same set of predetermined questions in the same order. This approach is fundamental to mitigating interviewer bias and guaranteeing consistency, creating a controlled environment for objective comparison. The benefits are extensively documented; structured interviews possess a higher predictive validity for job performance than their unstructured counterparts, establishing them as a more reliable tool for data collection [6].

3. Prepare Thoroughly

Thorough preparation is an absolute mandate for a valid interview. This involves a scrupulous review of the candidate's resume, cover letter, and any submitted portfolio items before the meeting. Leveraging the job scorecard, formulate a list of targeted questions designed to probe the candidate's competencies. A palpable lack of preparation is not merely unprofessional; it compromises the integrity of the interview and can even damage your organization's reputation. So, prepare for a job interview with the same diligence you demand from the candidate.

Streamline the Recruitment Process with Ringover

A business phone system provides effortless communication with your clients and candidates so you can focus on creating an inviting and impressive candidate experience.

Sign Up Today!

4. Craft Effective Behavioral Questions with the STAR Method

Behavioral questions, which compel candidates to recount past experiences (e.g., "Describe a time when..."), are formidable tools for gathering empirical evidence of past performance. To ensure you collect complete data, guide candidates to frame their responses using the STAR method:

• Situation: The specific context or background of the event.
• Task: The goal or responsibility they were assigned.
• Action: The concrete steps they took to address the situation.
• Result: The measurable outcome of their actions.

As the interviewer, your responsibility is to listen to all four components. This powerful framework ensures you receive a comprehensive dataset for each competency you are assessing [2].

5. Don't Rely on First Impressions

While first impressions are a natural cognitive shortcut, they are a notorious source of bias and can be profoundly misleading. Interviewers must make a conscious, deliberate effort to suspend snap judgments and concentrate on the data presented throughout the interview. While some of the biggest hiring icks, like lateness or clear unpreparedness, are valid red flags, other factors may simply be the product of nerves. Your final evaluation must be based on the candidate's qualifications and the substance of their answers, rather than initial emotional reactions.

During the Interview: Conducting a Meaningful Conversation

6. Create a Welcoming Atmosphere

To elicit the most authentic and insightful responses, you must cultivate an environment where the candidate feels comfortable. A welcoming atmosphere diminishes anxiety, empowering them to perform at their peak. Simple actions like a warm greeting, a clear self-introduction, and an outline of the interview agenda all contribute to this climate. For remote recruitment, this includes confirming the staffing technology works flawlessly and commencing with a brief, rapport-building chat. These foundational interview tips for recruiters help establish a professional yet approachable tone.

7. Set a Clear Agenda

Initiate the interview by lucidly explaining its structure. Inform the candidate how the time will be allocated–for instance, introductions, your questions, their questions, and a discussion of next steps. This proactive measure manages expectations, demonstrates profound respect for the candidate's time, and provides a framework that keeps the conversation focused, ensuring all critical areas are addressed [3].

8. Practice Active Listening

Active listening is a critical discipline for effective data collection during an interview. It demands your undivided focus on what the candidate is articulating, rather than simply awaiting your turn to speak. Techniques for active listening include maintaining eye contact, nodding to signal engagement, avoiding interruptions, and paraphrasing key points to confirm your comprehension. This not only makes the candidate feel valued but also ensures you capture more detailed and nuanced information [1].

9. Ask Probing, Open-Ended Questions

Move beyond simplistic yes/no inquiries. Employ open-ended and probing questions to galvanize candidates into providing detailed, evidence-based examples from their professional experience. Follow-up questions such as, "Can you elaborate on that?" or "What was the measurable outcome of that project?" are essential for digging deeper than surface-level responses and gathering robust evidence.

10. Avoid Dominating the Conversation

The primary objective of an interview is to gather information about the candidate. Adhere to the 80/20 rule as a guideline: the candidate should be speaking for approximately 80% of the interview. Resist the impulse to speak at length about your own experiences. Reserve the bulk of company and role information for the conclusion of the session, after you have completed your data gathering.

11. Steer Clear of Biased or Illegal Questions

All questions focus exclusively on job-related qualifications. Asking questions about a candidate's age, marital status, religion, children, or disability is not only illegal in many jurisdictions but also introduces profound bias and cultivates a negative candidate experience. Maintaining a disciplined focus on job-related competencies is crucial to a fair and legally compliant hiring process.

12. Sell the Company and the Role

An interview is a two-way evaluation. The candidate is appraising your organization with the same level of scrutiny you are applying to them. Reserve sufficient time at the end to answer their questions with transparency and enthusiasm. Be prepared to speak candidly about the company culture, team dynamics, opportunities for professional growth, and the specific challenges inherent in the role.

After the Interview: Making the Right Decision

13. Automate Note-Taking and Analysis

Taking detailed, accurate notes is vital for an objective comparison of candidates. However, attempting to take notes while practicing active listening is cognitively taxing and often yields incomplete or biased records. This is technological solutions like Ringover's business phone system and conversational AI come in to provide a transformative advantage. Interview transcription and conversational AI can automatically record, transcribe, and summarize interviews, creating an objective and complete account of the conversation. Advanced features like semantic analysis and talk-ratio scores offer deeper, data-backed insights, converting subjective conversations into quantifiable data points for a more scientific evaluation.

14. Communicate Next Steps and Timeline

At the conclusion of every interview, provide the candidate with an unambiguous explanation of the next steps in the hiring process. Furnish a realistic timeline for when they can expect a decision or further communication. This simple act of professionalism effectively manages candidate expectations and reflects positively on your employer brand.

15. Provide Timely Follow-Up and Feedback

Always follow up with every candidate according to the timeline you provided. Whether the outcome is a job offer, a rejection, or a delay, timely communication demonstrates respect for the candidate's time and effort. For candidates who are not selected, providing brief, constructive feedback is a professional courtesy that can enhance your employer brand and leave them with a positive impression of your organization [5].

Conclusion

Effective interviewing is not an art; it is a disciplined skill that demands rigorous preparation, a structured methodology, and a profound respect for the candidate. By systematically implementing these tips for interviewing candidates, hiring managers can successfully mitigate bias, make more informed, data-driven decisions, and ultimately construct stronger, higher-performing teams.

To elevate your hiring process with objective, data-backed insights, you must leverage technology designed to streamline and analyze your candidate conversations. Discover how Ringover's Empower platform can transform your interviews into actionable intelligence and lead to better hires.

Tips for Interviewing Candidates FAQ

What are the 5 C's of interviewing?

The 5 C's of interviewing are a simple framework to evaluate candidates consistently:

• Competence – whether the candidate has the skills and experience to do the job.
• Character – integrity, reliability, and how the candidate behaves under pressure.
• Culture fit – alignment with your company's values, team dynamics, and ways of working.
• Communication – the ability to listen, explain ideas clearly, and adapt their message.
• Commitment – motivation for the role and willingness to grow with the organization.

What are 5 good interview tips?

Here are five practical tips to improve your interviews:

• Prepare structured questions in advance to ensure fairness and consistency.
• Listen more than you talk to let candidates fully explain their experiences.
• Ask behavioral questions to understand how candidates acted in real situations.
• Take notes to capture key points and avoid relying on memory alone.
• Leave time for candidate questions to assess their interest and priorities.

What is the best way to interview candidates?

The best way to interview candidates is to combine structure with flexibility. Use a clear interview framework, ask the same core questions of every candidate, and evaluate answers against predefined criteria. At the same time, allow room for follow-up questions to explore relevant experiences in more depth. This approach improves objectivity while still encouraging natural conversation.

What is the 10 second rule in interview?

The 10 second rule refers to the idea that first impressions are formed very quickly—often within the first 10 seconds of meeting a candidate. For interviewers, this is a reminder to be aware of unconscious bias and avoid letting initial impressions overly influence the rest of the interview. For candidates, it highlights the importance of being prepared, professional, and confident from the very start.

Citations

• [1]https://www.carv.com/blog/interview-techniques-for-recruiters
• [2]https://capd.mit.edu/resources/the-star-method-for-behavioral-interviews
• [3]https://hbr.org/2025/01/how-to-structure-a-great-interview
• [4]https://hbr.org/1964/01/strategies-of-effective-interviewing
• [5]https://ung.edu/career-services/online-career-resources/interview-well/tips-for-a-successful-interview.php
• [6]https://www.cangrade.com/blog/talent-acquisition/6-benefits-of-a-structured-interview-process

Published on January 12, 2026.